About Scott Cleland
![]() |
|
You are hereIntellectual PropertyThe Deceptive Politics of PiracySubmitted by Scott Cleland on Wed, 2012-08-08 11:51In writing "Internet Pirates Will Always Win," Nick Bilton, The New York Times's technology columnist whom I read and respect, has unwisely adopted the political logic and public narrative of the piracy lobby that "information wants to be free." Unfortunately, I don't think Mr. Bilton has fully thought through the serious negative implications of his flawed logic and misplaced political support. Mr. Bilton is not the first, and won't be the last, columnist to buy into the piracy lobby's deceptive political narrative that fighting piracy is akin to a futile game of Whac-a-mole, so content creators should just unilaterally surrender the concept of market pricing of their content going forward and offer it free to the public on the Internet or at a minimal price that Internet pirates judge is "fair." Mr. Bilton concluded: "Sooner or later, the people who still believe they can hit the moles with their slow mallets might realize that their time would be better spent playing an entirely different game." The unspoken "different game" here is that the Internet should be more of a public information commons where everything is free of cost to access, and no permission or contract is required to do most anything on the Internet, in stark contrast to being more of an Internet marketplace where property owners of all kinds can charge for and contractually control the use of their property and individuals can assert control over how their private information is used. Google's Culture of Unaccountability: In their Own Words -- (Google Unaccountability Series: Part II)Submitted by Scott Cleland on Wed, 2012-08-01 10:54We learn about Google's culture-of-unaccountability from Google itself. Google's leaders have repeatedly indicated their hostility to accountability of most any type. Listen to Google's own words to learn about their unique and unabashed corporate culture-of-unaccountability. "New investors will fully share in Google's long-term economic future but will have little ability to influence its strategic decisions through their voting rights." Google's 2004 IPO letter to prospective shareholders from co-founders Larry Page and Sergey Brin. Questions to Ask at Google-Fiber AnnouncementSubmitted by Scott Cleland on Mon, 2012-07-23 15:17Listed below are pertinent questions to ask Google at its Google Fiber announcement July 26th, given Google's "launch-first, fix-later" philosophy, and its PR practice of omitting material facts and information. (See the Google-Kansas City Agreement here.) Google Mocks the WorldSubmitted by Scott Cleland on Fri, 2012-07-20 11:47Google has no shame. This week Google sponsored a two-day summit in Los Angeles entitled: "Illicit Networks: Forces in Opposition" and trumpeted Google's leadership in combating illicit networks, with no acknowledgement of Google's own uniquely atrocious track record of illicit network activity, and even worse, with no public acceptance of responsibility or remorse for Google's illicit behavior. There is no question that Google's professed public goals of combating "narco-trafficking, human trafficking, organ harvesting and arms dealing" are noble, needed and welcome. However, the serious problem here is Google's extreme cynicism and deceptive PR that they can burnish their global brand without having to practice what they preach. Let's have the evidence speak for itself, because it proves that Google is its own worst enemy, in not doing what they say. Googleopoly IX: Google-Motorola's Patents of Mass Destruction -- Reneging on Competitively-Essential Contract Arrangements is Patently Anti-CompetitiveSubmitted by Scott Cleland on Tue, 2012-07-10 11:42In Sao Paulo Brazil Launching My Search & Destroy Book in Portuguese -- see webcastSubmitted by Scott Cleland on Mon, 2012-07-02 21:56I am in Sao Paulo Brazil for the formal launch of the book I wrote with Ira Brodsky, Search & Destroy: Why You Can't Trust Google Inc., which now has been translated into Portuguese for the Brazilian market. The book launch press conference will be webcast live from a top Sao Paulo bookstore, Livraria de Vila, at 10:00 am EST Tuesday July 3rd, which will be attended by journalists, academics, students, and the public who will hear about the book and Google's adverse impact on privacy, competition, and intellectual property. My presentation will be webcast live at the Portuguese Search & Destroy site, Busque e Destrua, here. *** In May 2012, Search & Destroy was also published in Korean for the South Korean market. The English version can be found here.
Top Ten Untrue Google StoriesSubmitted by Scott Cleland on Tue, 2012-05-08 11:34The FCC's Google Street View wiretapping investigation proved that Google's public representations it was just a mistake one rogue engineer -- that the FTC and foreign law enforcement relied upon to close their investigations -- were untrue. Going forward, law enforcement must remember the old adage: "fool me once, shame on you; fool me twice, shame on me." I. Top Ten List of Untrue Google stories
Google's Rap SheetSubmitted by Scott Cleland on Tue, 2012-04-24 10:47Compare Google's law enforcement record here with Google's public representations below to determine for yourself if they match up.
Why Google Thinks It is Above the LawSubmitted by Scott Cleland on Tue, 2012-04-17 09:32Google often acts as if it thinks it is above the law. That may be the most plausible explanation for why Google is under antitrust investigation on five continents, has had 35+ privacy scandals, and has been sued for eight different kinds of infringement/theft from most every content industry. I. Cover-ups Pages |