You are here Spin can't magically turn the Maine net neutrality defeat into a win
Submitted by Scott Cleland on Tue, 2007-06-12 17:53
Public interest groups supportive of net neutrality like Common Cause and The Maine Civil Liberties Union are trying to "spin" the press that the non-binding net neutrality resolution passed by the Maine Senate is somehow an important first for a state.
- The reality is that supporters of net neutrality thought that the support of net neutrality by Dorgan-Snowe co-sponsor and Maine Senator Olympia Snowe would somehow increase the chances of passing net neutrality legislation for the first time in the state of Maine.
- They were wrong.
- This legislative effort in Maine failed just like it did in Michigan and Maryland, and just like it did in every Federal forum it was raised in.
- This Maine Senate "non-binding resolution" is simply hortatory puffery, akin to naming a state insect or a state weed.
- The reality is that the Maine legislature did not pass legislation and that it clearly acknowledged in its resolution its understanding that the Internet is exclusively Federal jurisdiction.
- There is nothing that could be more Federal or "interstate" than the "INTERnet!"
This episode in Maine really is emblematic of the whole net neutrality movement.
- Like "chicken little" net neutrality advocates scream that the Internet sky is falling, and then when it doesn't, they take credit for single-handedly saving the Internet from the sky falling.
- Like the "boy who cried wolf" they also get everyone scared that the broadband wolf-opoly is eating all the Internet sheep.
- However, like the villagers in the fable who discovered the boy lied about the wolf eating the sheep, lawmakers are learning that they can't believe what the net neutrality advocate say.
- That's why the net neutrality advocates keep moving on to new states and to new forums --
- they need to find new people they haven't misled yet.
»
|